← Beer guide

The economics of a brewery - why craft costs more

Reaching for a craft beer, you often pay two or three times more than for a macro lager from the supermarket. It is easy to think it is fashion, marketing or plain overpaying. The truth, however, is more down-to-earth and far more interesting: a small brewery simply operates in a different economy than a large corporation. At every step, from buying ingredients, through equipment and labour, to taxes and distribution, craft bears higher unit costs. In this post we will break the economics of a brewery down into its parts and show why craft beer has to cost more. Understanding these mechanisms will help you judge what you are really paying for, and whether this higher price makes sense. Spoiler: largely it does.

Scale: no economies of large production

The most important reason for the higher price of craft is the lack of economies of scale. A large corporation brews beer in gigantic quantities, spreading fixed costs over millions of litres, so the cost of producing a single beer drops to a minimum. A small brewery brews in small batches, so the same costs, of equipment, utilities, labour, spread over far smaller production. As a result the unit cost is much higher. This law of scale rules the whole industry: the more you produce, the cheaper each unit comes out. Craft deliberately gives up mass production for quality and variety, but pays for it with a higher cost per bottle. This one principle explains most of the price difference. A small brewery is not more expensive out of greed, but because it physically cannot achieve the savings that production on an enormous scale provides.

Ingredients: premium hops and malt

The second layer of costs is ingredients, in which craft aims far higher than mass beer. Macro lagers use economical recipes, often with additives that lower the cost. Meanwhile craft beers, especially hoppy ones, can consume enormous amounts of expensive hops. Modern IPAs and NEIPAs use several, even a dozen times more hops per batch than an ordinary lager, often in multiple charges of cold dry-hopping. On top of this, stronger beers require more malt to reach higher alcohol. Special malts, noble hop varieties and selected yeasts cost far more than basic raw materials. This generosity in ingredients builds flavour, but dramatically raises the cost of a batch. By paying for craft, you pay among other things for handfuls of expensive hops that simply are not in cheap beer. It is a real, tangible difference in the quality of raw material.

Equipment and investment debt

Starting and running a brewery is an enormous investment in equipment: fermentation tanks, brewing kettles, cooling systems, bottling lines. For a small brewery this equipment is very costly per litre of beer produced, because it serves a small scale. Many breweries finance it with loans, and the high instalments and interest burden every batch produced. A corporation will spread the cost of a production line over millions of litres, a small brewery over a fraction of that. On top of this come the costs of upkeep, maintenance and repairs. This investment debt and depreciation of equipment is an often invisible-to-the-consumer yet significant component of the price of beer. A small producer has to recover the money put into infrastructure by selling relatively little beer, which inevitably raises the price of a single bottle. Brewing equipment is simply expensive, regardless of scale.

Labour and time in the tanks

Craft is also more labour-intensive and slower. Small, frequent batches mean more human work per litre of beer: weighing ingredients, manual hopping, quality control, cleaning, packaging. Per bottle the cost of labour is higher than in automated, mass production. On top of this comes time. Many craft styles require long lagering and maturation, which means the beer occupies the tanks for weeks, blocking production capacity. The longer a batch sits in the tank, the fewer production cycles the brewery can fit in a year, which again raises the unit cost. Time is money, and craft often deliberately sacrifices speed for quality. This combination of greater labour input and a longer production cycle adds another layer to the price of craft beer, especially with more demanding styles.

Excise and taxes

Beer carries a considerable tax burden, which adds to the price. Excise, the tax on alcohol, and VAT are a significant part of what you pay in the shop. In the case of stronger beers, frequent in craft offerings, higher alcohol content often means higher excise. On top of this come various fees and costs of compliance with regulations, which for a small producer can be proportionally higher than for a large corporation with a whole legal and accounting department. Although some countries have excise reliefs for small breweries, the overall fiscal burden still strongly affects the final price. Taxes are an element the brewery has no influence over, yet which adds to every bottle. The consumer is often unaware how large a part of the price of beer is precisely levies for the state, rather than the producer’s profit.

Distribution and intermediaries

The journey of beer from the brewery to your fridge leads through a chain of intermediaries, each of whom adds their margin. A small brewery rarely sells directly to the consumer, more often through distributors, wholesalers and shops. In some countries, like the US, a rigid three-tier system applies, in which the brewery must sell to a distributor, the distributor to a shop, and only the shop to the consumer. Each link adds a margin and costs. A small producer has a weaker negotiating position than a corporation, so it gets worse terms. Transport of small, scattered batches is also more expensive per bottle. This layer of distribution and intermediation can significantly raise the shelf price relative to what the brewery actually earns. The consumer pays not only for the beer, but for the whole logistics of delivering it fresh to the shop shelf.

Marketing and thin margins

Contrary to appearances, the margins in craft beer are not at all fat. After subtracting the costs of ingredients, labour, equipment, taxes and distribution, the brewery is often left with little. Rising prices of raw materials and labour additionally squeeze this already thin margin, and competition in a crowded market does not allow prices to be raised freely. Many small breweries balance on the edge of profitability, and some go under. On top of this comes the cost of building a brand: labels, graphics, presence at festivals, social media, because without recognition it is hard to sell beer. Contrary to popular opinion, a high price rarely means a high profit for the producer, but rather covering real, high costs. It is important to understand that craft is not expensive because someone is raking in fortunes, but because the margin after all costs can be surprisingly modest.

Where the money from beer goes

Let us roughly set out what makes up the price of craft beer. The proportions vary, but the tendency is clear:

The table shows that a large part of the price is taxes and costs over which the brewery has limited influence. The producer’s profit is usually not the largest, but one of the smaller pieces of this pie.

Is craft overpriced

So is craft beer overpriced? In the light of economics, rather not - its price reflects genuinely higher costs of production at a small scale, from better ingredients and with greater labour input. This does not mean every expensive beer is worth its price, because quality varies, and marketing sometimes drives the price above value. Generally, however, you pay for specific, tangible differences: more hops, more careful production, freshness, variety of styles. If you value these things, the premium makes sense. If you treat beer purely functionally, a cheaper lager is entirely enough and there is nothing wrong with that. A conscious choice means understanding what you are paying for, rather than blindly buying the most expensive. We write more about the differences between craft and corporate beer in our post craft versus macro beer.

How to buy consciously

Since you now know the economics of craft, how do you buy wisely? First, pay attention to freshness, especially with hoppy beers, because expensive hops quickly lose aroma - a fresh IPA is worth its price, a stale one is not. Second, choose styles that genuinely benefit from a craft approach, like intensely hopped or complex, lagered beers. Third, do not overpay for hype alone: sometimes a brand’s renown drives the price above quality. Fourth, support local breweries by buying directly if you can, because you shorten the chain of intermediaries. Finally, try and record your impressions, to know which beers really give you value for their price. A conscious consumer pays for quality and freshness, not just the word craft on the label. This is the best way to make your money go where the quality actually is.

The key points in a nutshell

Craft beer is more expensive than macro mainly because of the lack of economies of scale: small batches spread costs over smaller production, so the unit cost rises. Added to this are expensive ingredients (loads of hops in IPA, more malt in strong beers), costly equipment and investment debt, greater labour input and long lagering that blocks tanks. Taxes, excise and VAT are a large, fixed part of the price, and distribution through intermediaries adds further margins. Despite high prices, the brewery’s margin can be modest. Craft is thus not overpriced, but reflects the real costs of quality. Want to record which beers give the best value for money? Keep notes in the GustoNote app. See also our posts on craft versus macro beer and the Polish craft beer revolution.